It was a big effort but I finally made my way uptown to try Marea.  All four of us, casually dressed, decided we might be a tad out of our element the second we saw each other.  The restaurant is beautiful, elegant and very adult.  Men were wearing jackets and a few ties, Fred was wearing a sweater.  Men were wearing nice slacks, Fred was wearing jeans.  It is nice to see how the other half dines. 

We had all read the same reviews on Marea.  The first few courses are fantastic but the main courses are not as wow.  So, in keeping with our tradition when we dine with our friends, we split everything.  It makes for great conversation. 

As we started looking through the menu, I took out a pen and marked up the menu and pulled it out of its folder.  Didn't realize it was glued in but figured they had an ample supply.  Poor manners on my part but watching all the waiters gape at me might have been worth it.  It did help us when the courses came. 

The first courses came from the Crudo al Taglio section of the menu.  Sliced raw fish and shellfish.  Sushi, Italian style.  Each plate comes out on small square different colored resin plates.  We each were served a plate, we'd take a bite or two and then pass to our right.

Lancia is sliced Hawaiian blue marlin with a dollop of sturgeon caviar over the top with a mussel vinaigrette drizzled across the plate.  Everybody voted this as number one.  The combination of the flavors and textures just hit a seriously high note.  Amazing.  My apologies for some poor picture quality.

Seppia was also a winner.  Cuttlefish cut into the shape of tagliatelle (a thin spaghetti) mixed with a soffrito and bottarga de muggine.  The mound of fish was laid over thinly sliced cucumbers.  Nice touch. 

Dentice is sliced pacific snapper that sits over whole wheat bread croutons.  This was not my favorite.  It was simple but it was clever and tasty but not as layered in flavor as the other crudos.

Polipo is simple but I really enjoyed it.  Sliced pieces of octopus with chili oil, lemon and parsley over the top.  I love the texture of octopus and the chili oil gave it a real spicy bite.  Yum.

This course was fantastic.  I not only loved the creativity of each dish but how each taste stood out even when there were 3 – 4 different flavors.  Every flavor complimented each other and although you were tasting a bunch of flavors at once, each taste individually stood out. 

Our next course was from the Antipasti section of the menu.  This consists of seasonal appetizers.  This was my least favorite course.  Although everything was exquisitely prepared, the flavors of the crudo were more powerful.

Astice is small pieces of poached lobster sitting over a creamy burrata and small pieces of eggplant and a sprig of basil.  The strange mixture totally worked.  The burrata was phenomenal.  Creamy and just delicious.

Ricciola is cured pieces of yellowtail sliced into a mound with meyer lemon, horseradish and piece of pistachio to compliment. 

Coppa di Testa is beautiful in presentation.  Whole anchovies wrapped around a spiced braised pork with tiny caramelized onions on the side.  Genius.  My only criticism of the dish is that the pork didn't have that much kick, it had no depth.

Calamari is squid stuffed with spicy sausage and sauteed kale and pieces of sunchoke on the the side.  This was really good, different and the presentation was pretty amazing.

Our last round was the pastas which have been praised by everyone who has eaten at Marea.  This is the part of the meal that we were all looking forward to. 

I Cotechino is a risotto made with spiced pork, cod belly and red wine.  This was so incredibly rich that it was almost too much.  A small dollop of this is plenty.  A whole plate kind of kills it.

  Funghi is wild mushrooms and shaved parmigiano.  Classic and fantastic.


Ferratini is manilla clams, pieces of calamari and hot chilies.  This pasta was divine.  Seriously out of this world.  Light spicy flavorful and perfectly cooked.  I loved loved loved this pasta.

2010-02-09 20.32.23
Fusilli is the pasta that everyone raves about.  Believe the hype.  Fusilli mixed with red wine braised octopus and bone marrow.  Honestly, it renders me speechless.  Deep in color, rich in flavor, different than any other sauce I have ever had over perfectly made pasta.  Awesome.

Last we did go for dessert, of course.  A creamy chocolate dessert like a torte with whole hazelnuts and a milk gelato on the side.  I think we got one more thing but honestly can't remember.  At this point, many glasses of wine, full bellies and still dreaming about the pastas, I was done.

Worth the journey.  There happens to be a private room downstairs.  Could be a great place for an intimate party.  Just a FYI.  I'm still dreaming about the fusilli, the ferratini and the lancia.  Seriously sublime. 

Comments (Archived):

  1. stevefried

    looks great. have been meaning to try. thx for sharing…

  2. kirklove

    1. Congrats on making it uptown. I knew you could do it. ; )2. You beat Lili and I by 48 hrs. Going tomorrow. Can’t wait.3. Poop on it being old and dressy. I’m not wearing a tie. No way.4. Everything sounds amazing. What’s your one or two must haves? Based on your write up sounds like it’s the Calamari and Ferratini.

    1. Gotham Gal

      The must haves are the Fusilli, the Ferratini and the Lancia. MUST! Let meknow what you think.

      1. kirklove

        Went last night. It was good not great. Certainly didn’t wow me, except for the Fusilli. That’s a game changer IMO.Full write up on my humble little blog if you’re so inclined.

        1. Gotham Gal

          I’ve heard mixed reviews. For us, it was probably keeping with the best parts of the menu, lots of wine and great company.joanne [email protected]