South Edison, Montauk

Montauk is the place to eat this summer.  The good news for us is that we are 15 minutes away.  Change has been happening in Montauk over the past couple of years and this summer has hit a new all time high.  Cynthia Rowley actually opened a shop on the main street.  Not sure if that is a good thing or a bad thing but a changing thing. 

South Edison opened last summer so this is a returning meal.  I went a few times last summer.  The menu, although changes daily, is consistent with last year.  The main courses weren't wowing me this time but could have just been my mood.  We opted to split a few things and stay light. 

We split some oysters that were fantastic.  Not sure who they are sourcing their oysters from but great job. A few classic sauces on the side including a chopped scallion Asian sauce was a nice touch.

Shisito peppers
Salt and Vinegar fried Shishito Peppers with a creme sauce are good but almost too spicy.  I had the same response last time.  It wasn't just one that hit me but most of them.  It you like spice then this is the perfect dish to share for the table.

Beet salad with local ricotta and greens with a few orange slices and marcona almonst, some grape tomatoes and both golden and red beets mixed with a sherry citrus vinaigrette is a nice summer salad.  Tasty with a variety of flavors is really good.

Lamb ribs.  Wow, wow, wow.  I am going to attempt to make this at home.  A rub of peppercorns, cumin, jalapenos, cilantro, chili oil and chiles is the perfect combo of spice.  My guess is the lamb is rubbed down and roasted in the oven for hours at a low temperature.  The lamb falls right off the bone and is unbelievably flavorful. 

The other high note was the octopus tacos.  Innovative and excellent.  Braised baby octopus with mushrooms, pickled red onions, roasted tomatos with a chili salsa, creme and a light cheese almost like a ricotta salata but more flavorful.  Excellent.  Another one to try at home this summer. 

Spicy tuna BLT.  This was on the menu last summer too.  Chopped spicy tuna wrapped in a tortilla with smoked bacon, heirloom tomatos, sliced chilis and fresh creme.  I like this and thought it was very clever last summer.  The only issue is that the bacon had been cooked earlier in the day and it wasn't crispy as it needed to be.  It was missing that bite.

Lamb ribs
For dessert we tried two things.  S'mores cake which was a chocoalte cake with marshmallow filling.  Kind of dry. 

Ice cream
The other dessert was an ice cream sandwich.  Rich flat brownie with salted caramel ice cream on top.  This was the winner.

There is something very beachy about South Edison.  I like it more as the days get warmer.  Love that they gave me two ideas to make home this summer.  Between the octopus taco and the lamb ribs, I will be back. 

Comments (Archived):

  1. ellen

    How many people were at dinner?I did not see the lamb on the menu?

    1. Gotham Gal


  2. Laura Yecies

    Thanks for the tip – wee’re in Montauk for the week and we will check it out – while I love Gosman’s and its emotional connection with family vacations growing up some more interesting dishes like this sound good.  Any other places you recommend in Montauk/Amagansett?

    1. Gotham Gal

      Joni’s for lunch in Montauk, Hideaway for tacos in Montauk, Crow’s Nest inMontauk.Hampton Chutney in Amagansett, La Fondita in Amagansett and the Clam Bar inNapeague.Great farmers market in Montauk on Wed.

      1. Laura Yecies

        South Edison was terrific – we fed my “daughter-in-law to be” her first raw oyster (she liked it) in addition to enjoying the octopus tacos, lamb ribs and beet salad the scallop ceviche and seared tuna were excellent.  My younger two kids had a burger and filet roast – not very creative but suited them.  The waiter recommended an excellent Sancerre that the adults all enjoyed. 

        1. Gotham Gal

          gotta love that. keep me posted on the others.

          1. Laura Yecies

            From South Edison

          2. Laura Yecies

            Had a nice brunch at Joni’s – felt like we were back in CA – noticed lots of Gluten free treats so I loaded up for my nephew who can’t have Gluten – he was glad to have many yummy desserts to enjoy while his cousins were indulging.Figure we’d pass on Mexican/Indian since that’s good in CA.Last night we took my parents to SurfSide on Old Montauk Highway – seafood with a southern flair – shrimp jambalaya on cheesy grits, ribs, salmon in a honey glaze (too sweet for me but the kids liked it) – quite a pleasant place with a pretty view of the ocean and nice dining room with good service – I would go again.  Particularly good fresh tomato soup (no cream which is how I like it) and arugala salad with parmesan and lemon vinaigrette. Tonight all 24 of us went back to Gosmans for a “farewell” dinner – I had steamers for appetizer and fluke for dinner – two things that I love and you can’t really get in California, great end to the vacation.